Why Not Start a Podcast in 2025?

Podcasts are everywhere. From business insights to niche hobbies, there’s a show for almost every interest. For startups eager to stay relevant, launching a podcast might feel like the logical next step. But is it really worth your time, effort, and resources? In this article, we’ll take a critical look at why podcasting might not always be the best strategic choice and outline what you should consider before starting one.

Why Podcasting Isn’t for Everyone

Podcasting sounds like a creative, high-impact marketing strategy, but the reality is often more complicated. Here’s why startups need to tread carefully:

1. It’s a Huge Commitment

Producing a podcast isn’t just about hitting the record button. You’ll need to:

• Plan topics and secure guests.
• Invest in quality recording equipment or studio time.
• Edit audio to ensure professional sound.
• Promote episodes across multiple channels.

Podcasting demands a significant investment of time and energy—two things most startups don’t have to spare. Between researching topics, scripting episodes, coordinating guests, and editing, a single episode can consume dozens of hours. For early-stage startups, every minute spent on a podcast is a minute taken away from critical growth activities like product development, customer acquisition, or securing funding.

2. The Competition Is Fierce

By 2025, the number of podcasts is expected to surpass 5 million. Standing out in this crowded space demands not just great content, but a unique angle and a lot of patience. Without a strong differentiator, your podcast risks becoming just another show in an already saturated market.

Competing against established shows with loyal listeners also makes it harder to gain traction. For instance:

• Established podcasts have brand recognition and SEO ranking, making it harder for a newcomer to be discovered.
• Listeners often stick with a few trusted podcasts rather than exploring new ones.

3. Difficulty in Building a Loyal Audience

Unlike quick, scrollable content on social media, podcasts require a significant time investment from listeners. Convincing your target audience to regularly dedicate 30–60 minutes of their time to your episodes can be a steep uphill battle. For startups still in the process of identifying and growing their audience, this adds an extra layer of complexity.

4. Tracking ROI Is Tricky

How do you measure the success of a podcast? Downloads? Listener feedback? Increased sales? Unlike ads or social media campaigns, a podcast’s impact is hard to quantify. For early-stage startups focused on growth metrics, this ambiguity can be a dealbreaker.

Consider:

• Podcast downloads or streams rarely translate directly into leads or sales.
• Metrics like listener engagement or brand awareness are often vague and difficult to tie back to specific business objectives.
• A podcast’s impact on your bottom line can take months (or years) to materialize—time most startups don’t have.

5. High Costs, Low Guarantees

While basic podcasting equipment might seem affordable, creating a high-quality show requires more than just a microphone. Costs can quickly escalate with:

• Professional audio editing software.
• Hiring editors, designers, or producers.
• Marketing to promote episodes.
• Hosting platforms and analytics tools.

6. Poor Execution Reflects Poorly on Your Brand

A podcast that lacks professional polish can do more harm than good. Consider these risks:

• Low production quality: Bad audio, awkward editing, or background noise can create a negative impression of your startup’s professionalism.
• Unengaging content: Rambling conversations, lack of structure, or irrelevant topics can bore your audience and hurt your brand.
• Inconsistent branding: A poorly executed podcast may dilute your brand messaging and confuse potential customers.

7. Podcasting Trends May Not Align with Your Audience

Not every target audience listens to podcasts. For example:

• If your audience skews older or less tech-savvy, they may prefer written articles, webinars, or videos over podcasts.
• In some industries, podcasts may not hold the same authority as white papers, research reports, or thought leadership articles.

Failing to align your marketing efforts with your audience’s preferences is a costly mistake that startups can’t afford.

‍

Pros and Cons of Starting a Podcast

To help you decide, let’s break down the potential benefits and challenges.

Advantages:

• Deeper Connections: Podcasts let you speak directly to your audience, building authenticity and trust.
• Content Repurposing: A single episode can be turned into blog posts, social media clips, and email content.
• Networking Potential: Inviting guests gives you the chance to build relationships with key industry players.

Challenges:

• Consistency Is Key: Successful podcasts require regular uploads, a task that can strain already limited resources.
• The Quality Bar Is High: Amateur production or inconsistent publishing schedules can hurt your brand image.
• The Payoff Is Slow: Gaining traction often takes months, with no guarantee of significant returns.

‍

Better Alternatives for Startups

If the risks outweigh the potential benefits, consider these more strategic ways to reach your audience:

1. Leverage Webinars or Live Events

Interactive formats like webinars are excellent for showcasing expertise and engaging with your audience in real-time. Plus, they require fewer resources and offer immediate feedback.

⏩️Maximizing Startup Growth Through Events

2. Be a Podcast Guest

Rather than launching your own show, appear on established podcasts in your niche. You’ll gain exposure to an existing audience without the ongoing commitment.

3. Double Down on Written Content

Blogs and articles not only improve SEO but also provide long-term value. They’re easier to produce, easier to scale, and can help you reach your audience when they’re searching for solutions.

4. Experiment with Video

Short-form video content on platforms like Instagram or TikTok can offer higher engagement rates and immediate visibility, especially for B2C startups.

⏩️ Unlocking the Potential of Video Marketing for Startups

When Podcasting Might Make Sense

Despite the challenges, there are scenarios where starting a podcast could align with your goals:

You Have a Built-In Audience

 If your startup already has a loyal following, a podcast can deepen relationships and foster stronger community engagement.

Your Audience Listens to Podcasts

 If you’re in a podcast-friendly niche (like tech or design), your show might resonate better than other formats.

You’re Ready to Commit

 Podcasts are a long game. If you can consistently deliver high-quality episodes for at least a year, they can become a valuable brand asset.

‍

The Final Word

Podcasting isn’t inherently bad—it’s just not the golden ticket for every startup. Before jumping in, ask yourself:

• Does my target audience even listen to podcasts?
• Do I have the resources to commit to high-quality production?
• Can I measure its impact on my business goals?

In most cases, startups are better off exploring more focused, measurable strategies for growth. However, if you’re prepared to play the long game and commit to excellence, a podcast could eventually become a powerful extension of your brand.

Ultimately, the question isn’t whether you can start a podcast—it’s whether you should.

⏩️ Startup Branding: Building a Foundation for Long-Term Growth

🎧 Listen to Pitchdrive’s Podcast: The Founder Frequencies

‍